Aretha Franklin’s Estate Dilemma

In her long and illustrious career, Aretha Franklin hit many milestones:  first female artist inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, winner of 18 Grammys and a host of chart-topping albums and singles. When she passed away on August 16, 2018, she was added to the long list of celebrities who failed to leave an estate plan. With an estate estimated to be worth tens of millions of dollars, it’s difficult to understand why she did not at least have a simple Will drawn up. This failure may expose Aretha Franklin’s estate and her family to a number of problems.

Potential Disputes Among Aretha Franklin’s Family

Intestacy – dying without a Will – can lead to disagreements over who will inherit and how estate assets will be distributed. Disputes can be fierce, leading to family feuds and lengthy court battles. However, under Michigan intestacy law, Ms. Franklin’s estate likely will be split evenly between her four sons.

Thus far, Ms. Franklin’s sons appear to be working together to settle her estate. A court filing in Michigan lists the sons as interested parties. The document also asked that Aretha Franklin’s niece, Sabrina Owens, be appointed the estate’s personal representative. Hopefully, the current spirit of cooperation between the sons and Ms. Owens will continue until the estate is settled.

Loss of Privacy for Aretha Franklin’s Estate

By all reports, and despite being a popular entertainer, Ms. Franklin tended to keep her personal life private. This is all about to change.

Had Ms. Franklin left a Will, it would have been submitted to the probate court and become public record. However, trusts usually do not become public record. In fact, that’s one of the advantages of adding at least a revocable living trust to an estate plan. Establishing a trust would have better protected the privacy of Ms. Franklin and her heirs.

Aretha Franklin’s Estate May Face a Large Tax Bill

Fortunately, tax reform raised the federal estate and gift tax limit to a little over $11,000,000. It’s too early to tell exactly how much Aretha Franklin’s estate will be worth after all debts have been paid. If it is over the tax limit, the estate may receive a tax bill for about 40% of the estate’s value in excess.

This is another area where trusts might have helped. Proper estate and tax planning could have put more money into the pockets of Ms. Franklin’s heirs instead of IRS coffers.

Aretha Franklin’s Estate Must Address Royalties and Copyrights

It appears that Ms. Franklin retained ownership and copyrights to much of her extensive catalog of music. Her estate and heirs could reap the benefits of her work for years to come. The question is: how will her estate handle her future earnings?

Special assets like Aretha Franklin’s catalog are often difficult to value. However, at some point an appraisal will be made in order to finalize the probate proceeding.

What Could Aretha Franklin Have Done Differently?

Even a simple Will could have prevented the potential disputes and disagreements facing Aretha Franklin’s estate. Better yet, establishing one or more trusts potentially would have minimized her estate’s tax burden, passed assets privately and quickly to her heirs, and prevented family disputes.

At Law Offices of John Mangan, P.A., we help clients choose estate planning strategies that meet their needs. Please contact us at 772-324-9050 to schedule an appointment or fill out our Contact Form. We are located in Palm City, Florida, and serve clients in surrounding communities like Stuart, Hobe Sound, Port St. Lucie, and Jupiter, too.

Written by John Mangan, Esq.

John Mangan, Esq.

I’m an attorney in Palm City, FL, and I serve clients throughout Martin County, including Stuart, Palm City, Hobe Sound, and Indiantown, as well as those in St. Lucie County, the Treasure Coast, Palm Beach County, and other parts of Florida. The Law Offices of John Mangan, P.A., is an innovative firm providing estate planning services to clients in Florida. We focus primarily on wills, trusts, asset protection, guardianship, and probate administration.